Difference between revisions of "Between Wilkins and Taylor"
From Wythepedia: The George Wythe Encyclopedia
(→See also) |
m (→Evidence for Inclusion in Wythe's Library) |
||
| (38 intermediate revisions by 4 users not shown) | |||
| Line 6: | Line 6: | ||
|commontitle= | |commontitle= | ||
|vol= | |vol= | ||
| − | |author=George Wythe | + | |author=[[:Category:George Wythe|George Wythe]] |
|editor= | |editor= | ||
|trans= | |trans= | ||
| − | |publoc= n.p. (Richmond, VA?) | + | |publoc= n.p. ([[:Category:Richmond|Richmond, VA]]?) |
|publisher= n.p. (Thomas Nicolson?) | |publisher= n.p. (Thomas Nicolson?) | ||
| − | |year=n.d. ( | + | |year=n.d. (1799?) |
|edition= | |edition= | ||
|lang= | |lang= | ||
|set= | |set= | ||
|pages=30,(1) | |pages=30,(1) | ||
| − | |desc=8vo (20 cm.) | + | |desc=[[:Category:Octavos|8vo (20 cm.)]] |
| − | }} | + | }}''[[Media:WytheBetweenWilkinsAndTaylor1796.pdf|Between Wilkins and Taylor]]''<ref>George Wythe, [[Media:WytheBetweenWilkinsAndTaylor1796.pdf|''Between, Joseph Wilkins, Administrator of His Late Defunct Wife Sarah, One of the Grandaughters and Legataries of Thomas Williamson, and Widow, When She Was Married Last of Hartwell Cocke, Plaintiff, and, John Taylor, and William Urquhart, Executors of the Said Thomas Williamson, Defendents'' [''sic''] ]](Richmond, VA: Thomas Nicolson, 1799?).</ref> is a published opinion by [[George Wythe]], for the case ''[[Wilkins v. Taylor]],'' Wythe 338 (1799), in Virginia's High Court of Chancery.<ref>George Wythe, ''[[Decisions of Cases in Virginia by the High Court of Chancery (1852)|Decisions of Cases in Virginia by the High Court of Chancery with Remarks upon Decrees by the Court of Appeals, Reversing Some of Those Decisions]],'' 2nd ed., ed. B.B. Minor (Richmond: J.W. Randolph, 1852), 338.</ref> The report was published in pamphlet form in 1799 or later—almost certainly printed by Thomas Nicolson of Richmond, Virginia, who had published [[Decisions of Cases in Virginia, by the High Court of Chancery|Wythe's Reports]] in 1795, and at least seven other supplements for Wythe, in 1796 and after.<ref>Charles Evans, in his ''[[American Bibliography]],'' vol. 11 (1942), estimates the date of publication as 1796.</ref> |
| − | George Wythe, | ||
| + | B.B. Minor, editor of the second edition of Wythe's Reports in 1852, summarizes the case, thusly: | ||
| + | |||
| + | <blockquote> | ||
| + | Bequest of the interest of stock to testator's daughter for life; then said interest over equally to testator's grandchildren; and "at their decease principal and interest to be disposed by them to their heirs, in such proportions ah they, by their wills, respectively, may direct; and in case of the death of grandaughter S. C. without issue, her part to grandaughter E. C." | ||
| + | |||
| + | The Chancellor ''held,'' that this was only a bequest of ''the interest,'' to the grandchildren, who were to reserve the principal and distribute it among their heirs respectively. The Court of Appeals ''held,'' it was an absolute gilt to said grandchildren after said daughter's deith, and, confirming the decree of the County Court, reversed that of the H. C. C., in the Appeal, 5 Call, 150. | ||
| + | |||
| + | The same point is involved in ''Goodwyn v. Taylor,'' 4 Call, 305; S. C. 2 Wash. 74; and decided the same way.<ref>Wythe, ''Decisions'' (1852), 338.</ref> | ||
| + | </blockquote> | ||
==Evidence for Inclusion in Wythe's Library== | ==Evidence for Inclusion in Wythe's Library== | ||
| − | Wythe's | + | Upon his death, a copy of this pamphlet which had belonged to Wythe was [[Last Will and Testament|bequeathed with his books]] to [[Thomas Jefferson]]. Jefferson had the pamphlet bound into a volume with seven of Wythe's other Chancery decisions which were published as supplements.<ref>"Six tracts originally bound together in calf for Jefferson by Milligan on June 30, 1807 (cost $1.00). Rebound in Buckram for the Library of Congress." E. Millicent Sowerby, comp., [http://hdl.handle.net/2027/mdp.39015033648109?urlappend=%3Bseq=222 ''Catalogue of the Library of Thomas Jefferson''] (Washington, D.C.: Library of Congress, 1953), 2:208 [http://babel.hathitrust.org/cgi/pt?id=mdp.39015033648109;view=1up;seq=223 [1763]].</ref> Subsequently, the volume became part of the collection at the Library of Congress, titled on the spine: ''Wythe's Reports. Supplement. Virginia. 1796-99.''<ref>This volume contains pamphlets for: ''[[Case upon the Statute for Distribution]]'' (1796); ''[[Field v. Harrison]]'' (1794); ''[[Fowler v. Saunders]]'' and ''[[Goodall v. Bullock]]'' (1798, together in the same pamphlet); ''[[Wilkins v. Taylor]]'' (1799); ''[[Yates v. Salle]]'' (1792); and ''[[Love v. Donelson]]'' (1801). See also: ''[[Aylett v. Aylett]]'' (1793), and ''[[Overton v. Ross]]'' (1803).</ref> The pamphlet for ''Between Wilkins and Taylor'' has a handwritten notation, "no. 5," on the first page.<ref>For the pamphlet numeration, see [http://www.worldcat.org/title/between-joseph-wilkins-administrator-of-his-late-defunct-wife-sarah-one-of-the-grandaughters-and-legataries-of-thomas-williamson-and-widow-when-she-was-married-last-of-hartwell-cocke-plaintiff-and-john-taylor-and-william-urquhart-executors-of-the-said-thomas-williamson-defendants/oclc/7139803 WorldCat.]</ref> |
| + | |||
| + | This pamphlet contains an errata sheet on the last page; Wythe made manuscript notations in his hand, correcting the errors.<ref>"Manuscript corrections by Wythe." [http://hdl.handle.net/2027/mdp.39015033648109?urlappend=%3Bseq=223 Sowerby, 2:209.]</ref> | ||
<gallery widths=300px heights=500px perrow=3> | <gallery widths=300px heights=500px perrow=3> | ||
| − | File: | + | File:BetweenWilkinsAndTaylor1796P1.jpg|Page one from [[George Wythe|George Wythe's]] pamphlet, ''Between Wilkins and Taylor'' (1799?). Library of Congress copy. |
| − | File: | + | File:BetweenWilkinsAndTaylor1796P5.jpg|Page five from Wythe's pamphlet, ''Between Wilkins and Taylor'' (1799?), with Wythe's emendation. Library of Congress copy. |
| − | File: | + | File:BetweenWilkinsAndTaylor1796P10.jpg|Page ten from Wythe's pamphlet, ''Between Wilkins and Taylor'' (1799?), with Wythe's emendation. Library of Congress copy. |
| − | File: | + | File:BetweenWilkinsAndTaylor1796P16.jpg|Page 16 from Wythe's pamphlet, ''Between Wilkins and Taylor'' (1799?), with Wythe's emendations. Library of Congress copy. |
| − | File: | + | File:BetweenWilkinsAndTaylor1796P22.jpg|Page 22 from Wythe's pamphlet, ''Between Wilkins and Taylor'' (1799?), with Wythe's emendation. Library of Congress copy. |
| − | File: | + | File:BetweenWilkinsAndTaylor1796Errata.jpg|Errata notice for Wythe's pamphlet, ''Between Wilkins and Taylor'' (1799?). Library of Congress copy. |
</gallery> | </gallery> | ||
| − | |||
| − | |||
| − | |||
==See also== | ==See also== | ||
| − | + | *[[American Bibliography]] | |
*[[Between Fowler and Saunders]] | *[[Between Fowler and Saunders]] | ||
*[[Between Yates and Salle]] | *[[Between Yates and Salle]] | ||
| − | *[[Case of | + | *[[Case of Overtons Mill: Prolegomena|The Case of Overtons Mill: Prolegomena]] |
*[[Case upon the Statute for Distribution (pamphlet)]] | *[[Case upon the Statute for Distribution (pamphlet)]] | ||
| − | *[[Love against Donelson | + | *[[Decisions of Cases in Virginia by the High Court of Chancery (1852)|''Decisions of Cases in Virginia by the High Court of Chancery with Remarks upon Decrees by the Court of Appeals, Reversing Some of Those Decisions'']] |
| + | *[[Love against Donelson]] | ||
*[[Report of the Case between Aylett and Aylett]] | *[[Report of the Case between Aylett and Aylett]] | ||
*[[Report of the Case between Field and Harrison]] | *[[Report of the Case between Field and Harrison]] | ||
| + | *''[[Wilkins v. Taylor]]'' | ||
| + | *[[Wythe's Library]] | ||
| + | |||
| + | ==References== | ||
| + | <references/> | ||
==External Links== | ==External Links== | ||
| + | |||
| + | *[http://indexvirginiaprinting.org/imprint/1796.024/ Index of Virginia Printing.] | ||
| + | *[https://lccn.loc.gov/22003057 Library of Congress catalog record.] | ||
| + | *[http://hdl.handle.net/2027/mdp.39015033648109?urlappend=%3Bseq=223 Sowerby Catalogue,] at HathiTrust. | ||
[[Category:Case Reports]] | [[Category:Case Reports]] | ||
| + | [[Category:Chancery Reports]] | ||
| + | [[Category:George Wythe]] | ||
| + | [[Category:Jefferson's Books]] | ||
[[Category:Known Surviving Wythe Volumes]] | [[Category:Known Surviving Wythe Volumes]] | ||
| + | [[Category:Pamphlets]] | ||
[[Category:Titles in Wythe's Library]] | [[Category:Titles in Wythe's Library]] | ||
[[Category:Virginia Reports]] | [[Category:Virginia Reports]] | ||
| + | |||
| + | [[Category:Octavos]] | ||
| + | [[Category:Richmond]] | ||
Latest revision as of 15:38, 8 November 2019
by George Wythe
| Between Wilkins and Taylor | ||
 at the College of William & Mary. |
||
| Author | George Wythe | |
| Published | n.p. (Richmond, VA?): n.p. (Thomas Nicolson?) | |
| Date | n.d. (1799?) | |
| Pages | 30,(1) | |
| Desc. | 8vo (20 cm.) | |
Between Wilkins and Taylor[1] is a published opinion by George Wythe, for the case Wilkins v. Taylor, Wythe 338 (1799), in Virginia's High Court of Chancery.[2] The report was published in pamphlet form in 1799 or later—almost certainly printed by Thomas Nicolson of Richmond, Virginia, who had published Wythe's Reports in 1795, and at least seven other supplements for Wythe, in 1796 and after.[3]
B.B. Minor, editor of the second edition of Wythe's Reports in 1852, summarizes the case, thusly:
Bequest of the interest of stock to testator's daughter for life; then said interest over equally to testator's grandchildren; and "at their decease principal and interest to be disposed by them to their heirs, in such proportions ah they, by their wills, respectively, may direct; and in case of the death of grandaughter S. C. without issue, her part to grandaughter E. C."
The Chancellor held, that this was only a bequest of the interest, to the grandchildren, who were to reserve the principal and distribute it among their heirs respectively. The Court of Appeals held, it was an absolute gilt to said grandchildren after said daughter's deith, and, confirming the decree of the County Court, reversed that of the H. C. C., in the Appeal, 5 Call, 150.
The same point is involved in Goodwyn v. Taylor, 4 Call, 305; S. C. 2 Wash. 74; and decided the same way.[4]
Evidence for Inclusion in Wythe's Library
Upon his death, a copy of this pamphlet which had belonged to Wythe was bequeathed with his books to Thomas Jefferson. Jefferson had the pamphlet bound into a volume with seven of Wythe's other Chancery decisions which were published as supplements.[5] Subsequently, the volume became part of the collection at the Library of Congress, titled on the spine: Wythe's Reports. Supplement. Virginia. 1796-99.[6] The pamphlet for Between Wilkins and Taylor has a handwritten notation, "no. 5," on the first page.[7]
This pamphlet contains an errata sheet on the last page; Wythe made manuscript notations in his hand, correcting the errors.[8]
Page one from George Wythe's pamphlet, Between Wilkins and Taylor (1799?). Library of Congress copy.
Page five from Wythe's pamphlet, Between Wilkins and Taylor (1799?), with Wythe's emendation. Library of Congress copy.
Page ten from Wythe's pamphlet, Between Wilkins and Taylor (1799?), with Wythe's emendation. Library of Congress copy.
Page 16 from Wythe's pamphlet, Between Wilkins and Taylor (1799?), with Wythe's emendations. Library of Congress copy.
Page 22 from Wythe's pamphlet, Between Wilkins and Taylor (1799?), with Wythe's emendation. Library of Congress copy.
Errata notice for Wythe's pamphlet, Between Wilkins and Taylor (1799?). Library of Congress copy.
See also
- American Bibliography
- Between Fowler and Saunders
- Between Yates and Salle
- The Case of Overtons Mill: Prolegomena
- Case upon the Statute for Distribution (pamphlet)
- Decisions of Cases in Virginia by the High Court of Chancery with Remarks upon Decrees by the Court of Appeals, Reversing Some of Those Decisions
- Love against Donelson
- Report of the Case between Aylett and Aylett
- Report of the Case between Field and Harrison
- Wilkins v. Taylor
- Wythe's Library
References
- ↑ George Wythe, Between, Joseph Wilkins, Administrator of His Late Defunct Wife Sarah, One of the Grandaughters and Legataries of Thomas Williamson, and Widow, When She Was Married Last of Hartwell Cocke, Plaintiff, and, John Taylor, and William Urquhart, Executors of the Said Thomas Williamson, Defendents [sic] (Richmond, VA: Thomas Nicolson, 1799?).
- ↑ George Wythe, Decisions of Cases in Virginia by the High Court of Chancery with Remarks upon Decrees by the Court of Appeals, Reversing Some of Those Decisions, 2nd ed., ed. B.B. Minor (Richmond: J.W. Randolph, 1852), 338.
- ↑ Charles Evans, in his American Bibliography, vol. 11 (1942), estimates the date of publication as 1796.
- ↑ Wythe, Decisions (1852), 338.
- ↑ "Six tracts originally bound together in calf for Jefferson by Milligan on June 30, 1807 (cost $1.00). Rebound in Buckram for the Library of Congress." E. Millicent Sowerby, comp., Catalogue of the Library of Thomas Jefferson (Washington, D.C.: Library of Congress, 1953), 2:208 [1763].
- ↑ This volume contains pamphlets for: Case upon the Statute for Distribution (1796); Field v. Harrison (1794); Fowler v. Saunders and Goodall v. Bullock (1798, together in the same pamphlet); Wilkins v. Taylor (1799); Yates v. Salle (1792); and Love v. Donelson (1801). See also: Aylett v. Aylett (1793), and Overton v. Ross (1803).
- ↑ For the pamphlet numeration, see WorldCat.
- ↑ "Manuscript corrections by Wythe." Sowerby, 2:209.
